Guard Retention

Quick Introduction

Guard retention is the art and science of maintaining your guard when opponents attempt to pass. It's one of the most critical skills in BJJ - you can't attack from guard if you can't keep it. Mastering retention principles transforms your guard from a temporary position into a sustainable platform for attacks.

Position Overview

Station: Guard System

Applies to: All guard types - closed, open, half, butterfly

Core Objective: Prevent opponent from achieving immobilization while maintaining offensive capacity

Leads to: Guard recovery, sweeps, submissions, position transitions

---

Why Guard Retention is Critical

The Foundation of Guard Play

Guard retention is the prerequisite for everything else:

• Can't sweep if guard is passed
• Can't submit from bottom side control
• Can't score points from defensive positions
• Can't implement your guard game plan

The defensive-offensive cycle:

1. Retain guard against passing attempts
2. Create opportunities from their failed passes
3. Attack with sweeps and submissions
4. Return to retention when threatened

Competition Reality

In competition, guard retention determines outcomes:

• Points: Passed guard = 3 points to opponent
• Position: Leads to mount (4 more points) or back (4 more points)
• Submissions: Most submissions come from top position
• Energy: Defending from bad positions is exhausting

Key insight: Better to spend energy on retention than recovery from bad positions.

---

The Hierarchy of Defensive Frames

Understanding the defensive frame hierarchy is fundamental to guard retention. Each frame represents a line of defense.

🥇 Line 1: Feet on Hips/Knees (Primary Defense)

Why it's strongest:

• Maximum distance from danger
• Longest limbs creating largest frames
• Legs are stronger than arms
• Multiple guard options available

Applications:

• Feet on hips in open guard
• Butterfly hooks engaged
• De La Riva hooks active
• Spider guard frames

Key principle: Fight to maintain foot frames first - once lost, harder to recover

Tactical use:

• Creates space for movement
• Allows offensive attacks
• Prevents pressure from building
• Energy efficient

🥈 Line 2: Knees (Secondary Defense)

Why it's important:

• Last barrier before they control hips
• Knee shield in half guard
• Can still create angles
• Bridge to recovering foot frames

Applications:

• Knee shield half guard
• Knee frame in guard recovery
• Blocking chest-to-chest connection
• Creating space for re-guarding

Key principle: When feet are compromised, immediately establish knee frames

Common mistake: Passive knees that don't actively frame

🥉 Line 3: Hands/Arms (Tertiary Defense)

Why it's weaker:

• Shorter levers than legs
• Arms are weaker
• Closer to being passed
• More energy intensive

Applications:

• Cross-face defense
• Underhook battle
• Frames against chest pressure
• Emergency guard recovery

Key principle: Use hands to support leg frames, not replace them

Tactical use:

• Prevent head control
• Fight for underhooks
• Create space for legs to re-enter
• Last line before accepting position change

The Frame Priority System

Always work to restore higher-priority frames:

1. If feet are lost: Use hands/knees to create space → re-insert feet
2. If knees are threatened: Hip escape to restore foot frames
3. If only hands remain: Emergency movement to prevent immobilization

Never accept:

• Flat on back with no frames
• Both legs passed
• Cross-face with no defensive frames
• Static position while being passed

---

Hip Movement Fundamentals

Hip movement is the engine of guard retention. Without it, even perfect frames will fail.

🦐 Shrimping (Hip Escape)

What it is: The fundamental defensive movement - creating angle and distance by pushing hips away

Execution (Step by Step):

1. Turn on side (don't stay flat on back)
2. Plant outside foot on mat
3. Bridge up slightly
4. Push with planted foot
5. Slide hips back and away
6. Create angle and space

When to use:

• Guard is being passed
• Need to re-establish distance
• Recovering from compromised position
• Creating angle for attacks

Key details:

• Must be explosive, not slow
• Creates space for legs to re-enter
• Prevents flat-on-back position
• Foundation for all guard recovery

Common mistakes:

• ⚠️ Shrimping straight back instead of at angle
• ⚠️ Not turning on side first
• ⚠️ Slow, gradual movement instead of explosive
• ⚠️ Shrimping without purpose or destination

🤸 Granby Roll

What it is: Inverted rolling movement to create space and change facing

Execution:

1. Tuck chin to chest
2. Roll over shoulder (not over head)
3. Drive with legs through the roll
4. Come out facing opponent
5. Re-establish guard immediately

When to use:

• Legs are completely passed to one side
• Need to change facing quickly
• Opponent has leg control
• Setting up berimbolo or inversion attacks

Key details:

• Requires neck and shoulder flexibility
• Creates maximum space quickly
• Advanced movement for blue belt+
• Can disorient opponent

Tactical advantage: Converts bad position to neutral or offensive

🌊 Hip Escape Sequences

Single Hip Escape:

• One shrimp to create space
• Re-insert near leg
• Recover guard immediately

Double Hip Escape:

• First shrimp creates initial space
• Second shrimp recovers full guard
• Common in knee shield recovery

Continuous Hip Movement:

• Never stop moving hips
• Create angles constantly
• Opponent can't settle into passing position
• Foundation of modern guard retention

---

Re-Guarding Concepts

Re-guarding is the active process of recovering guard from compromised positions.

The Re-Guard Sequence

Step 1: Prevent Immobilization

• Create any frame available
• Don't let them settle into control
• Buy time for movement

Step 2: Create Space

• Hip escape to make distance
• Use frames to push them away
• Bridge to relieve pressure

Step 3: Re-Insert Leg(s)

• Get knee between you and opponent
• Recover butterfly hook
• Establish foot frame on hip
• Return to guard position

Step 4: Restore Control

• Establish grips immediately
• Regain defensive frames
• Return to attacking mindset

Common Re-Guarding Scenarios

From Half Guard Being Passed

Situation: Opponent clearing your leg to pass

Response:

1. Immediately hip escape away
2. Frame with outside hand
3. Get bottom knee to mat
4. Butterfly hook with free leg
5. Recover to full guard or sweep

From Open Guard Legs Passed

Situation: Both legs passed to one side

Response:

1. Turn to side immediately (don't stay flat)
2. Inside elbow frames on mat
3. Hip escape to create space
4. Re-insert bottom leg first
5. Recover guard position

From Collapsed Closed Guard

Situation: Closed guard broken, opponent driving forward

Response:

1. Don't try to re-close immediately
2. Create frames (feet on hips)
3. Establish grip controls
4. Either re-close or transition to open guard
5. Attack from recovered position

The Recovery Window

Understanding timing:

• Early defense (best): Recognize pass attempt, defend immediately
• Mid defense (acceptable): Legs compromised, still have frames
• Late defense (emergency): Only hands remain, must act now
• Too late (accept and move): Already passed, transition to escape

Key principle: Earlier you recognize the threat, easier the retention

---

Guard Recovery Sequences

Specific step-by-step sequences for common situations.

Sequence 1: Knee Slide Pass Defense

Recognition: Opponent slides knee across while controlling legs

Defense:

1. Inside hand frames on their shoulder
2. Hip escape away from sliding knee
3. Outside foot hooks their far hip
4. Inside leg re-inserts (knee shield)
5. Recover to half guard or open guard
6. Immediately establish grips

Key timing: Must hip escape before knee fully slides

Sequence 2: Over-Under Pass Defense

Recognition: One arm under leg, one arm over

Defense:

1. Prevent them locking hands together
2. Frame on face with bottom hand
3. Top leg kicks over their back
4. Bottom leg creates butterfly hook
5. Hip escape and recover guard
6. Attack with sweeps immediately

Critical point: Cannot defend flat on back - must turn

Sequence 3: Toreando (Bullfighter) Pass Defense

Recognition: Standing, throwing your legs to side

Defense:

1. Don't let legs hit mat fully
2. Follow their movement with hips
3. Immediately replace feet on hips
4. Recover grips on pants/sleeves
5. Re-establish open guard
6. Create off-balance

Key principle: Stay mobile, match their movement

Sequence 4: Leg Drag Defense

Recognition: Dragging your leg across your body

Defense:

1. Hip escape toward dragged leg
2. Free hand posts on mat
3. Top leg lifts over their arm
4. Bottom leg escapes back
5. Recover butterfly or open guard
6. Grip fight immediately

Timing: Before they secure cross-face

---

When to Fight vs When to Accept

Not all situations require stubborn guard retention. Strategic position transition is important.

Fight to Retain When:

✅ You have energy remaining

• Can execute defensive movements
• Not completely exhausted
• Can still create frames

✅ Your guard is working

• Getting sweeps and submissions
• Controlling opponent effectively
• Winning position battle

✅ In competition with time/points

• Need to prevent points
• Leading on points, prevent catch-up
• Time advantage from guard

✅ You have strong retention skills

• Practiced guard recovery
• Confident in retention sequences
• Better from guard than other positions

Accept Position Change When:

❌ Completely exhausted

• Cannot create frames
• No energy for hip movement
• Better to conserve and escape later

❌ Guard being consistently passed

• Not effective against this opponent
• They have your number
• Better to change strategy

❌ Better opportunity elsewhere

• Can secure better position through transition
• Sweep opportunity by "allowing" pass
• Strategic position change

❌ Injured or protecting injury

• Joint or limb at risk
• Leg under dangerous pressure
• Better to escape than risk injury

Strategic Acceptance vs Giving Up

Strategic acceptance means:

• Conscious decision
• Plan for next position
• Energy conservation
• Tactical advantage

Giving up means:

• No plan
• Demoralized
• Allowing complete control
• No learning or adaptation

Key difference: Strategic acceptance includes preparation for what comes next

---

Grip Fighting from Bottom

Grips are the foundation of guard retention - control grips, control the game.

Defensive Grip Priorities

🎯 Priority 1: Prevent Their Grips

Why it matters:

• Can't pass effectively without grips
• Harder to attack with no control
• Forces them to expend energy

How to implement:

• Constant grip stripping
• Active hands on their wrists/sleeves
• Deny collar and pants grips
• Make them work for every grip

Common grips to prevent:

• Cross collar (enables control)
• Belt or pants (enables leg control)
• Sleeve grips (controls your frames)
• Ankle grips (dangerous for passing)

🎯 Priority 2: Establish Your Grips

Why it matters:

• Control their posture
• Create frames with connection
• Setup sweeps and attacks
• Dictate engagement

Essential grips:

• Collar and sleeve (classic control)
• Two-on-one (dominant grip)
• Sleeve and pants (modern control)
• Underhooks (close range dominance)

🎯 Priority 3: Maintain Grip Advantage

Why it matters:

• Better grips = better retention
• Grip battles determine position
• First to secure dominance wins

Strategy:

• Never grip battle without plan
• Use legs to support hand grips
• Break their grips before they set
• Constant adjustment and fighting

Specific Grip Strategies

Against Standing Passer:

• Sleeve grips prevent driving forward
• Collar prevents good posture
• Pants grips control base
• Two-on-one creates off-balance

Against Kneeling Passer:

• Cross collar controls posture
• Underhook prevents crossface
• Wrist control prevents posting
• Sleeve prevents reaching

Against Pressure Passer:

• Fight for inside position
• Frames more important than grips
• Create space first, then grip
• Don't get gripped in flat position

See detailed grip concepts

---

Connection to Guard Dynamics

Guard retention is one side of the eternal battle described in guard dynamics.

Understanding the Battle

The passer's progression:

1. ⚔️ Pass the feet (Line 1)
2. ⚔️ Defeat the knees (Line 2)
3. ⚔️ Control the hips (Line 3)
4. ⚔️ Dominate shoulders/head (Line 4)

Your retention response:

1. 🛡️ Maintain feet on hips/knees
2. 🛡️ If compromised, restore knee frames
3. 🛡️ If lost, use hands to create space
4. 🛡️ Hip escape to recover higher frames

Space Creation and Filling

Creating space (Your objective):

• Shrimping/hip escape
• Bridging to relieve pressure
• Frames to push them away
• Technical stand-up when appropriate

Filling space (Preventing their objective):

• Keep knees between you and them
• Don't allow inside position
• Control center line with legs
• Protect flanks (hips to armpits)

Active vs Passive Retention

Active retention (Correct):

• Constant hip movement
• Attacking while defending
• Frame creation and adjustment
• Threatening sweeps/submissions

Passive retention (Incorrect):

• Static position hoping they fail
• No offensive threats
• Purely defensive mindset
• Eventually gets passed

Key principle: Best retention includes offensive threats

---

Important Observations (General Rules)

Core Principles

1. 🎯 Frames are hierarchy - Feet > Knees > Hands, always restore higher frames
2. 💪 Hips must move - Static hips = passed guard
3. ⏱️ Early recognition - Defend the attempt, not the completed pass
4. 🔄 Attack from defense - Threatened passes create sweep opportunities
5. 🎮 Strategic choices - Know when to fight vs when to transition

Connection to Theories

Applying core principles:

• Space Management: Create space for legs, fill space to prevent passing
• Hip Control: Your hip movement determines guard retention success
• Body Lines: Maintain defensive frame lines described in guard dynamics
• Leverage: Use legs (stronger) before arms (weaker)

Common Mistakes

⚠️ Staying flat on back - No defensive power, easy to pass

⚠️ Static hip position - Cannot recover without movement

⚠️ Fighting with arms only - Neglecting superior leg frames

⚠️ Late recognition - Defending after already half-passed

⚠️ No grip fighting - Allowing them perfect control grips

⚠️ Passive mindset - Defending without attacking

⚠️ Overcommitting to one frame - Not transitioning when necessary

⚠️ Accepting flat position - Must stay on side with frames active

---

🎓 Training Progressions

Solo Drills

1. Hip Escape Chain (3 minutes each side)

   • Continuous shrimping down mat
   • Focus on explosiveness
   • Turn on side each rep
   • Build muscle memory

2. Granby Roll Practice (10 reps each shoulder)

   • Proper shoulder roll technique
   • Don't roll over head
   • Build comfort with inversion
   • Foundation for advanced retention

3. Frame Transition Drill (5 minutes)

   • Feet to knees to hands sequence
   • Practice restoring higher frames
   • Build awareness of frame hierarchy
   • Solo movement pattern

4. Guard Recovery Flow (3 minutes)

   • Simulate being passed
   • Practice recovery sequences
   • Continuous movement
   • Mental rehearsal

Partner Drills

Level 1: Frame Recognition (Cooperative)

• Partner slowly attempts pass
• You identify correct frame
• Practice feet, knee, hand hierarchy
• 10 reps understanding principles

Level 2: Retention Sequences (25% Resistance)

• Partner attempts specific passes
• You execute proper retention sequence
• Light resistance to learn timing
• 5 reps each pass type

Level 3: Grip Fighting + Retention (50%)

• Partner tries to establish passing grips
• You fight grips and retain guard
• Moderate resistance
• 3-minute rounds

Level 4: Live Guard Retention (100%)

• Partner passes, you retain
• Full resistance
• Reset to guard each time
• 5-minute rounds, focus purely on retention

Common Drill Sequences

Drill 1: Knee Slide Defense Repetition

1. Partner sets up knee slide pass
2. You execute defense sequence
3. Recover to guard
4. Reset and repeat
5. 20 reps building automaticity

Drill 2: Four Corners Guard Recovery

1. Start with legs passed left
2. Recover to guard
3. Legs passed right
4. Recover to guard
5. Continuous for 3 minutes

Drill 3: Grip Fight to Retention Flow

1. Partner establishes passing grips
2. You strip grips
3. Establish your control grips
4. Partner attempts pass
5. You retain with proper frames
6. 5 minutes continuous flow

See drilling concepts

Progression Timeline

Following training methods:

• Week 1-2: Hip escape fundamentals, frame awareness
• Week 3-4: Basic retention sequences (knee slide, toreando)
• Month 2-3: All major pass defenses, grip fighting
• Month 4-6: Live retention, combining with attacks
• Blue belt+: Advanced movement, granby, inversions

---

🔧 Troubleshooting Guide

Problem: Guard Gets Passed Constantly

Solutions:

1. Recognize pass attempts earlier
2. Never stay flat on back - turn on side
3. More hip movement, less static holding
4. Study guard dynamics deeply
5. Improve grip fighting from start
6. Practice specific pass defenses in drilling

Problem: Can't Create Space for Re-Guarding

Solutions:

1. More explosive hip escapes
2. Use frames before trying to move
3. Turn on side first, then shrimp
4. Practice solo shrimping more
5. Strengthen core for bridging power

Problem: Don't Know Which Frame to Use

Solutions:

1. Default to feet on hips when possible
2. Use knee shield when feet compromised
3. Hands only as emergency measure
4. Drill frame hierarchy until automatic
5. Watch video of your rolling to see patterns

Problem: Exhausted from Retention Battle

Solutions:

1. More efficient movement (technique over effort)
2. Attack more (best defense is offense)
3. Strategic position acceptance when appropriate
4. Better cardio conditioning
5. Don't fight already-passed positions

Problem: Grips Keep Getting Broken

Solutions:

1. Establish grips earlier
2. Use two hands on their one
3. Constant re-gripping, never give up
4. Better grip fighting fundamentals
5. Support hand grips with leg frames

---

💡 Advanced Concepts

The Retention-Attack Loop

Concept: Best guard retention includes offensive threats that prevent clean passing.

Implementation:

1. Opponent attempts pass
2. You defend and retain
3. Their failed pass creates opening
4. You attack sweep/submission
5. They defend your attack
6. Cycle repeats

Why it works:

• They can't commit fully to passing
• Must respect your offensive threats
• Creates hesitation and openings
• More energy-efficient than pure defense

Predictive Retention

Concept: Anticipate pass attempts before they happen.

How to develop:

1. Study common passing sequences
2. Recognize grips that telegraph passes
3. Feel weight shifts before movement
4. Defend the setup, not the execution

Indicators to watch:

• Grip changes (preparing for pass)
• Weight shifts (loading for movement)
• Posture changes (setting up angle)
• Breathing patterns (preparing explosion)

The Give-to-Take Principle

Concept: Sometimes allowing partial pass creates better counter opportunities.

Applications:

• Let knee slide partially in to hit sweep
• Allow leg drag attempt to take back
• Give them heavy investment in failed pass
• Use their commitment against them

Warning: Requires experience and timing - advanced blue belt+

Competition-Specific Retention

Strategic considerations:

When leading on points:

• More conservative retention
• Don't risk sweeps that expose to pass
• Run time with strong retention
• Accept safer guard positions

When behind on points:

• More aggressive retention-attack
• Take risks for sweep opportunities
• Can't afford to just defend
• Push the pace

When tied:

• Balance of safety and offense
• Look for clear sweep opportunities
• Avoid being passed at all costs
• Stay active to prevent stalling calls

---

🎯 Belt-Level Expectations

White Belt Goals

Referenced in Beginner's Journey:

• Understand frame hierarchy (Month 1-2)
• Execute basic hip escape (Month 1-2)
• Defend knee slide and toreando passes (Month 3-4)
• Recognize when guard is being passed
• Don't stay flat on back

Blue Belt Development

Referenced in Skill Progression:

• All fundamental pass defenses
• Smooth guard recovery sequences
• Active grip fighting
• Granby roll competency
• Retention-attack integration
• Can retain against other blue belts

Purple Belt Mastery

• Advanced retention movements
• Predictive defense
• Can retain against brown/black belts
• Teaching retention to others
• Competition-level retention
• Personal retention system developed

---

🎯 Next Steps

After understanding guard retention fundamentals:

1. Master hip escape → Foundation of all retention
2. Learn frame hierarchy → Feet > Knees > Hands
3. Practice specific pass defenses → Knee slide, toreando, over-under, leg drag
4. Integrate grip fighting → Study grips
5. Combine with attacks → Retention creates sweep opportunities
6. Study guard dynamics → Understand the battle
7. Apply in live rolling → Test retention under pressure

🔗 Related Resources

Guard System Concepts

• Guard System Overview - All guard types and concepts
• What is Guard - Fundamental guard philosophy
• Guard Dynamics - The battle between guard and pass
• Grips & Connections - Essential grip strategies
• Body as Lines - Four defensive lines in detail

Specific Guard Positions

• Closed Guard - Retention with legs locked
• Open Guard - Distance management retention
• Half Guard - Knee shield and underhook retention
• Butterfly Guard - Hook-based retention

Theoretical Foundation

• Principles & Theories - Space and hip control
• Body Reading - Understanding structure
• Central Line and Flanks - Space control zones
• Training Methods - How to practice effectively

Progress Tracking

• Beginner's Journey - White belt retention development
• Skill Progression - Blue belt retention mastery
• Drills - Retention-specific training
• Quick Reference - Gym-ready guides

---